Evidence of the Impact of Substitutions in Goethite on Rare Earth Element Adsorption
Abstract
Since the 1980's the uses, and thus mining, of Rare Earth
Elements (REE) have grown exponentially. This has led to
questions about the impact of REE on the environment, and REE
being designated emerging pollutants. Currently, knowledge
about the behaviour of REE in the environment is still
incomplete. For example, there are few studies on REE
adsorption on iron (Fe) (oxy)hydroxides, which are considered
key carriers of metal pollution, and on the other factors
controlling this adsorption [1-4]. Knowing that in natural
(oxy)hydroxides, Fe is frequently substituted by other elements
in the environment in which they form, we were interested in the
effect of these substitutions on the adsorption capacity of
(oxy)hydroxides towards REE.
This study focusses on aluminium (Al, common in natural
environments and easily substituted into Fe-oxyhydroxides) and
gallium (Ga, chemical analogue to Al) substitutions in goethite
(Goe), representative of commonly found Fe-(oxy)hydroxides
whose well-defined structure allows for modelling of sorption
and surface interactions. For this purpose, experiments of REE
were conducted on pure and substituted goethites (Goe) with
varying Al and Ga content.
A characterisation of these goethites, shows that the
substitution does not affect the shape, size, and specific surface
area significantly. Nevertheless, the REE adsorption patterns are
affected by substitutions: 5% substitution decreases the sorption
capacity of the goethite, and at 10% substitution the preferred
adsorption of the mid and heavy REE diminishes, resulting in a
'flatter' pattern. Meanwhile, the Neodymium (Nd) L3-edge
EXAFS experiments show no modification of its binding mode
to the Goe surfaces, forming corner sharing bidentate-binuclear
complexes regardless of the substitution rate. However, TEM
observations and Cerium (Ce) L 3-edge XANES experiments
demonstrate that the Ga substitution favours a higher Ce(IV)O2
adsorption, while the Al substitution favours Ce(III) adsorption
compared to the pure Goe.
These results reveal the large impact of substitutions on the
reactivity of goethite towards REE.