W-band Radar Observations for Fog Forecast Improvement: an Analysis of Model and Forward Operator Errors

Alistair Bell (1) , Pauline Martinet (1) , Olivier Caumont (1) , Benoît Vié (1) , Julien Delanoë (2) , Jean-Charles Dupont (3) , Mary Borderies (1)

1 CNRM - Centre national de recherches météorologiques
2 SPACE - LATMOS
3 LMD - Laboratoire de Météorologie Dynamique (UMR 8539)

The development of ground based cloud radars offers a new capability to continuously monitor the fog structure. Retrievals of fog microphysics is key for future process studies, data assimilation or model evaluation, and can be performed using a variational method. Both the one-dimensional variational retrieval method (1D-Var) or direct 3D/4D-Var data assimilation techniques rely on the combination of cloud radar measurements and a background profile weighted by their corresponding uncertainties to obtain the optimal solution for the atmospheric state. In order to prepare for the use of ground-based cloud radar measurements for future applications based on variational approaches, the different sources of uncertainty due to instrumental, background, and the forward operator errors need to be properly treated and accounted for. This paper aims at preparing 1D-Var retrievals by analysing the errors associated with a background profile and a forward operator during fog conditions. For this, the background was provided by a high-resolution numerical weather prediction model and the forward operator by a radar simulator. Firstly, an instrumental dataset was taken from the SIRTA observatory near Paris, France for winter 2018–19 during which 31 fog events were observed. Statistics were calculated comparing cloud radar observations to those simulated. It was found that the accuracy of simulations could be drastically improved by correcting for significant spatio-temporal background errors. This was achieved by implementing a most resembling profile method in which an optimal model background profile is selected from a domain and time window around the observation location and time. After selecting the best background profile a good agreement was found between observations and simulations. Moreover, observation minus simulation errors were found to satisfy the conditions needed for future 1D-var retrievals (un-biased and normally distributed).

Domains: Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics [physics.ao-ph]; Meteorology

Alistair Bell, Pauline Martinet, Olivier Caumont, Benoît Vié, Julien Delanoë, et al.. W-band Radar Observations for Fog Forecast Improvement: an Analysis of Model and Forward Operator Errors. Atmospheric Measurement Techniques, 2021, 14 (7), pp.4929-4946. ⟨10.5194/amt-14-4929-2021⟩. ⟨insu-03098554v2⟩